Deserving Rich, Greedy Poor & thoughts on why I voted

I voted early. I will wake up in Stockholm when the general election result comes through. I might seek asylum and send for my family.
The last few days of the election are usually a grotesque spectacle on the newsagent’s floor, as the press’s excessive spin and propaganda reveals why you can’t trust it any other time of year until you’ve done a few background checks on the information they splash about. Somehow, previously positive traits, tolerance, kindness, generosity, altruism, have been turned into delusions and facets to be ashamed of. These, we are told, are the aims of the foolish and molly coddled.
I can’t remember a time where the belief in the divine right of the wealthy has been so apparent.
The perks of the wealthy are richly deserved, aid to the poor, the ill and the old is a terrible burden.
It’s all your fault.
I am at the lower end of the wealthy.
I am all right.
I did it all myself.
With the added assistance of being from a comfortable middle class background and with the usefulness of being white and male.
I went to a public school.
The same one that the film director Lindsay Anderson went to. He returned to it to make If… , a powerful attack on the values and divisions Britain was built on.
The school allowed him to film there, and when they saw the result he was persona non grata for a couple of decades.


When I see Boris Johnson, I see the power of the public school narrative. Day in and day out, the pupils are told that they are the very best people in society. They are the leaders. They will know best. In an abject failing of critical thinking and scepticism, many come to believe that.
It is right that they should rule, they know their Latin and their wines.
We are told to build a better house, a higher wall, a wider loft conversion, but not to build a better culture and civilisation. That is too costly.
The right wing manifesto has been that we must sell our services to the corporations, the Omnicorps of today, and they’ll make it all better while charging more and creaming more off the top because they deserve it.
Does childhood poverty ever worry you as you are driven to your second home in Cornwall?
Why is it that this society can only be seen to function effectively if those at the top are paid so much more than used to be necessary in 1978?
A few years ago, I went to see a Dennis Potter double bill, Blade on the Feather and Traitor, at the BFI. It was introduced by his producer and friend, Kenith Trodd. Both plays dealt with men who had betrayed others, men of privilege who had consorted with Russia and caused the death of others. These were upper class men, men of privilege. Trodd said that Potter believed the upper class had no love of their country. It was to be found in the other classes, but what concerned many of the upper class, whether it was with Nazis or Communists, was how much would they get. As long as they were deserving in the eyes of the new regime, all was good.
This is what worries me about BREXIT. There is such talk of “control” and “sovereignty”, yet we sell our utilities across the world and we may well find ourselves increasingly bending our knees to even uglier regimes. Rather than gain our freedom, we may have made ourselves even more captive to others.
I do not believe any political party can fulfil our dreams. I do not believe any of them are populated by so many thinkers and activists of depth and understanding that we will build a Utopia, but I do believe there are some who are not as mean-spirited, as selfish and as intolerant as others. I believe some dare to imagine a better life for more people.
I voted Labour, though I would not have been ashamed to vote for the Green party or LibDems either.
After World War 2, there were a few decades of trying to improve society for the majority. The programme to dismantle this has now gone on for longer than the programme to build it, is it possible to slow this advance, to stop hating our neighbours, to understand others, to offer the embattled and broken the possibility of hope? Or have we reached the phase where kindness, tolerance and ambition for a better society for all will be buried beneath tribalism and narcissism?

For those at the top, I suppose the thought is either “I want more” or “I want more people to have the comforts I take for granted.” I should add this is all motivated by selfishness. I don’t want to feel miserable walking down the street and seeing increasing numbers of homeless people and reading about childhood poverty. I want to think, “this is a society trying to make it better for more people”,  with me, it’s all me me me really.

FOOTNOTE – some of the things I want when I vote.
A decrease in preventable deaths and an NHS where those who work in it do not feel beaten and unacknowledged.
Better treatment for the elderly.
A strong and fair education system.
Effective action to deal with climate change.
Effective action against childhood poverty.
The list is long, I’ll stop there.
(and I am prepared to pay more tax for this. I have a good life, why shouldn’t more people have that. And before the normal snide “well, you can opt to contribute more income tax you know” comes my way, if a party of higher taxation does not win, I will pay the excess income tax I would have paid to a charity.)

I am off to the Edinburgh Fringe and gadding about the UK and Australia this Autumn, click for details – Barnard Castle to Folkestone and much in between.

Advertisements
This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

14 Responses to Deserving Rich, Greedy Poor & thoughts on why I voted

  1. Pete says:

    A very sensible, sound and well written article. And how lovely to be out of the country, as the election draws near, and miss the last minute frenzy of fake news, slanderous insults, lies and gutter press scaremongering!

  2. David says:

    I know the feeling. I was born into a different background, very middle of the road. Comfortable but not rich, state educated, like millions of others.
    I was lucky, left school at 16 but got a job sad an apprentice back when an apprenticeship was a proper thing and not an excuse to pay people very low wages to do a necessary job.
    I got on, craftsman, someone noticed I was quite bright, they paid for me to do more education. I ended up being a properly qualified engineer. I earn well. My route to a comfortable existence is all but closed now and that feels wrong.
    Those in need of work are exploited and those that can’t find it are demonised. The country has turned a corner, it’s become intolerant and disengaged, uncaring and even spiteful.
    The right of the country haven’t tried to fix it, they’ve exploited it to make it feel less comfortable with itself. They’ve removed its self confidence whilst pretending it’s patriotism. Patriotism is a feeling, not just a flag.
    It’ll turn again, but not yet. We’ll have to feel more pain before the healing begins.

  3. liliannberg says:

    Loved your blog, sensible and sensitive. Hope you’ll enjoy waking up in beautiful Stockholm, the city of my birth. The overbearing patriotic fervour of the Swedish National Day (6th of June) should be over by then, hopefully. Open your eyes to what is lurking under the cheerful blue-and-yellow surface . not quite as pretty as the stunning harbour vistas and canals of the “Venice of the North”. I left Sweden long ago and became a naturalized Aussie. Not so much a mistake as a major disappointment. Now exiled from both my countries I dream of a star far, far away…

    PS Don’t forget to visit the Museum of Modern Art (Moderna Museet) and the National Gallery (National Museum) both within walking distance of each other, Have fun

  4. Ben says:

    Reblogged this on Ben Swift.

  5. David E says:

    I echo many of these sentiments. It’s very sad that the membership of the Labour party have allowed the Conservatives a free 5-year term by putting up a leader so diametrically opposed to where most swing voters sit. It didn’t have to be this way.

  6. nostalgiaman says:

    Very well put, Sir. Sadly more weight to it as you were educated with money. You are probably better educated than most as a result which is obviously just wrong.

    All problems described above become harder to solve with a growing population. Education is the easiest and most effective solution to reduce population. Technology will help but it is a long way from preventing poverty – too far away. Fail to reduce population and history(lots of it) has shown that we creatures will get meaner as the competition for scarce resource grows. Basic income seems a viable method to prevent slavery as we work towards a smaller and more equal global society.

  7. Reddan says:

    Thank you, from a working class disabled lady, if only there we many more like you 🙂

  8. Helen Brown says:

    Enjoyed your piece very much. Thanks. Wish I was off to the Fringe; enjoy. Edinburgh; hame of my faither.

  9. keithakenny says:

    Unfortunately, many people believe political parties will fulfill their dreams … they have less confidence in themselves even though the best things in life come rather cheaply. Our politicos major talent is being popular, i.e. telling us what we want to hear, about ourselves, our problems, the world. No actually knowledge is required beyond polling data.

    In our recent election, a reality show blowhard who entered the election on a whim defeated the champion of liberal brilliance. While this is the logical result of hubristic foolishness, people are unable to point out the fools. Really tough that one.

    I look at the real solvable problems of the world—perhaps maybe getting a quality education for the less-than-elite children in our nations capitol—and I look at what is getting all the attention—holding hands and doing a rain dance no one thinks will change the temperature, and btw something that will be a lot easier and cheaper than a trillion dollars with the technology we’ll have in a hundred years, if the problem still exists.

  10. Barbara Anglezarke says:

    Just BRAVO Robin!

  11. Mari Smith says:

    Thank you for putting into words everything that I feel…. xxxxx

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s