Doctor Who and The March for Science

It appears that there is a condition of “Doctor Who fanboy by proxy”. Arriving at the Science museum to take part in the London Science March, there was Peter Capaldi.
It was the beat that my heart skipped.
Not for me, for my son.
He was at home.
He had done his march for the year.
Halfway around on the Women’s March, he had been told to try to be less bored.
‘I am 9 years old, you’d have been bored on a march when you were 9,” he told my wife.
You couldn’t fault his logic.
My son didn’t spot any noticeable or notable Timelords on the Women’s March (though some were there I am told), just a Gandalf, and he hasn’t got into Middle Earth as yet.
I was embarrassed, but there was no choice.
I felt I had to get a photo and an autograph for my son.


I have been fortunate to work with on shows with many icons, including a James Bond and USS starship captain. I have not asked for their signature.
The last autograph I felt I had to get was Peter Andre for my niece in 1998. By the time I got her the signed piece of paper, she’d moved on to other popstars.
Vanessa Furey, one of the organisers of the march, kindly guided me over, and brokered the signature on a T shirt and photo deal.
Clearly, I am still not in showbiz.

Peter Capaldi took part in the march, happily mixing in a crowd that was trying to come up with chants that were both scientifically accurate and catchy.
Freethinking scientists are not used to this sort of thing, which might explain why there was a sad lack of well-known scientists and science broadcasters in attendance.
Some were apparently fearful of appearing “political”, isn’t it too late for science to shy away from the Westminster fray?
Sadly, vaccination, climate change and research budgets are political issues.
Andrew Steele, of Science is Vital, Brenna Hassett of Trowelblazers, and me of some kind of Monkey Cage, set about composing chants.
“What do we want?”
“Cats in a superposition”
“when do we want them?”
“Until observed”
didn’t catch on.
“Science – good at asking questions
Not so Good at slogans”
made it as far as Trafalgar Square.
“Science not silence” and “What do we want? Evidence based policy. When do we want it? After peer review”, made it to Westminster. (I missed this one – “What do we want?” “Climate change!” “When do we want it?” “Over geological timescales!”)
There were 12000 people there.
12000 people concerned by the rebuilding of walls around curiosity and national boundaries stymying the scientific adventure.
12000 people eager to encourage everyone around them to be scientifically curious.
12000 people worried that the charlatans I trying to drown out scientific endeavour.
12000 people who savour looking through telescopes on a clear night and lying on grass looking at the night sky as a multitude of stars increasingly come into focus.
12000 people who want the lives of human beings to continue to improve.
I thought about how science fiction had educated me.
I thought about how Doctor Who’s stories have so often incorporated ideas of tolerance and understanding those that may seem odd.
Francisco Diego’s speech reminded us all of the shared heritage of all humans on earth.
How slight is the difference in our codes, how hastily we leap on these minor surface differences and declare them reasons for animosity.
Tolerance and curiosity are achievements, we need to find as many ways and times to celebrate this and to work out the most effective way of fighting for it.
There are many vindictive “contrarian” creeps who delight in increasing unhappiness, who are tottering lickspittles for money interests that have little human interest, they are not keen on curiosity and delight, it makes them nauseous and uneasy. Sadly, their ugly, unmannerly thoughts and gestures are rating bonanzas and revenue enhancing clickbait. There is a clammy cluster of scientific naysayers who are so busy sneering they haven’t noticed that they’re not dead from smallpox or cholera.
We need to find new and more effective ways of showing that fascination and delight are more potent and rewarding.
Talking to someone born in 1939 who was critically ill, they express their concern that they may have lived in the best time to be a European human, a time when they didn’t have to fight in a war, where medicine made enormous leaps, hot and clean water was readily available, and technology was creating all manner of machines of wonder. I don’t want to be in the first retrograde generation.
I want my son’s life to be better than mine just as mine has been better than my grandparents and I don’t want to have to use a TARDIS to make that possible.

I am on tour in the Autumn including Barnard Castle, Salford, Leeds, Nottingham, York and more. I will also be doing two separate Edinburgh Fringe shows – Pragmatic Insanity and Rorschach Test. Oh, and I have a book out in September.

Here is Brian Cox’s Chaos of Delight .

This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to Doctor Who and The March for Science

  1. Bill Hargreaves says:

    Loved this post, thanks Robin. Also loved seeing you in the Mechanics Hall in Marsden, helping to save the library. Hope to catch you in Lancs or Yorkshire later in the year

  2. Reblogged this on Homo economicus' Weblog and commented:
    “Sadly, vaccination, climate change and research budgets are political issues.” I have to agree with Robin Ince. Those that have a special interest to go against science are heavily political. They need push back. It will take scientific personalities that can engage the public; that kind of politics is in the public interest. Sometimes to advance science you need to get out of the labs, and in to the streets.

  3. riveranglican says:

    Reblogged this on Dour Mouse and commented:
    “At the beginning of every disaster movie is a scientist being ignored” sign seen on the march for science.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s